SFKS succeeded in Appealing against Costs Order

Announcement
|
November 18, 2026

SFKS successfully represented our clients in an appeal against a Master’s costs order in CSIL Limited v Alpha Apex Global Limited and Others [2026] HKCFI 6260. The Court set aside the costs order involving a sum of HK$1.8 million costs for an interlocutory application.

This Decision is noteworthy in the sense that it is a well-established legal principle that a judge will not overturn a Master’s costs order unless it is shown that the order was unreasonable, that the Master erred in law, or that the Master took into account irrelevant factors or failed to take into account relevant factors. 

Despite the uphill battle in appealing against a discretionary costs order, our side has managed to convince the judge that the Master’s exercise of discretion in making the costs order was wrong, unreasonable and untenable.  In particular, the judge found that the Master’s determination on costs was premature, unfair and wrong in principle. 

This case is led by our Founding Partner Mr. Peter Sit, assisted by our Partner Mr. Sidney Ho, Senior Associate Ms. Koey Wong, Associate Ms. Chloe Fan, Paralegal Ms. Janice Leung, and Trainee Solicitor Ms. Carissa Chan. 

Please refer to the Decision of Deputy High Court Judge Alan Kwong dated 12 November 2026.

‍

Document Download

< Back to previous page